Breakage with 6.10
marlowsd at gmail.com
Mon Oct 13 05:25:57 EDT 2008
Ian Lynagh wrote:
> On Fri, Oct 10, 2008 at 03:54:07PM -0700, Duncan Coutts wrote:
>> On Fri, 2008-10-10 at 15:34 -0700, Don Stewart wrote:
>>> arrows fails due to:
>>> [ 3 of 12] Compiling Control.Arrow.Transformer.CoState ( Control/Arrow/Transformer/CoState.hs, dist/build/Control/Arrow/Transformer/CoState.o )
>>> Module `Control.Arrow' does not export `pure'
>>> Even though cabal-install decided to use base-184.108.40.206
>>> So that means base-3 is *not* exporting quite the same interface as last time.
>>> Were we aware of this?
>> Note that this means that base-3 should have the version number 3.1.x.y
>> because there is at least one incompatible api change. We're promoting
>> the versioning policy so we need to follow it ourselves in our base
> I don't think that that really helps. If you're going to depend on base
> 3.1, you might as well just depend on base 4 and be more future-proof.
> The base-compat package needs to claim to have the same API as the old
> base, because the point is that things just keep on working (except in
> the few cases, like the Arrow split, where that isn't possible).
Hmm, this is quite annoying. We simply *can't* provide the same API as
base-3.0.2 without defining a new Arrow class, and that would kill
compatibility with base-4. On the other hand, we did know this could
happen (changes to datatypes also cause the same problem), it's the
tradeoff with trying to provide base-3 as a compatibility layer over base-4.
So the options are:
* if we are honest and call it base-3.1, then everyone else has
to lie and use dependencies like base==4.*. If they use dependencies
like base==4.0, which are more correct, then these packages will
break in GHC 6.12 if we have to ship base-4.1 rather than 4.0.
* we lie (a bit) and call it base-3.0.3.
so the total amount of dishonesty is reduced if we pick the second option :-)
Perhaps we've found a use for the second digit of the major version number.
More information about the Glasgow-haskell-users