Remove eq and show from num class

Anthony Clayden anthony_clayden at clear.net.nz
Fri Sep 8 10:59:41 UTC 2017


> On 2017-09-08 at 08:43 AM, Herbert RIedel wrote:

Thank you Herbert for the explanation.

>> On 2017-09-08 at 09:19:54 +0200, Anthony Clayden wrote:
> 
> [...]
> 
> I can see how the proliferation of committees & github
> repos may seem confusing to casual observers, ...

Not that so much. I saw:

A message from Carter about lunch queues.
A new topic from Carter with a 5-word Subject line,
 not saying it was a proposal;
 saying something about some committee approving something;
 with a smiley;
 several more messages with smileys (a couple from you).
 
That doesn't seem to follow the process
in the link you sent.

Nothing saying this is a proposal.
Nothing explaining or motivating.
Now you're referring me back to a 2011 version of some
proposal.
It's hardly providing context.
To repeat: think about all the Haskellers reading this list.

So for anybody not at ICFP (I'm not)
what's going on?
Are you just a bunch of clowns joking around?
It doesn't seem to be April 1st.

This from you is relevant:

> ## Haskell Core Library Committee
>
> ... (the CLC was originally formed sometime around 2013
> to design and manage big changes such as the
implementation of
> the Functor/Applicative/Monad proposal --
> for which there was big community support but lack of
leadership was
> preventing its implementation).

Whether or not everything under the FTP
were sensible changes (I think not),
the actual communication of what was to change was lousy,
and the consultation/decision process was rushed at the end.
There are still people grumbling about it.

You seem at risk of repeating that.


AntC


More information about the Haskell-prime mailing list