[Haskell-cafe] Please critique my code (a simple lexer)

wren ng thornton wren at freegeek.org
Wed May 23 05:55:27 CEST 2012

On 5/22/12 11:13 AM, John Simon wrote:
> - Is `case _ of x:xs ->  x:xsr where xsr = something xs` a common
> idiom? It happened twice in my code, and it seems odd to split the
> first element away from the rest of the list as it's processed.

I don't know how common it is in practice, but that's fmap for the 
PreList functor. Allow me to explain...

(tl;dr: there's some non-trivial theoretical backing, if you're 
interested in recursion theory. Though again, I'm not sure how often it 
actually comes up for lists.)

Here's the list type, if we defined it ourselves:

     data List a = Nil | Cons a (List a)

Like other recursive types, we can decompose this into a non-recursive 
type plus a generic version of recursion:

     data Fix f = MkFix (f (Fix f))
     -- N.B., MkFix :: f (Fix f) -> Fix f

     data PreList a recurse = PreNil | PreCons a recurse

     type List' a = Fix (PreList a)

The new List' is essentially the same as the old List:

     to :: List a -> List' a
     to Nil         = Fix PreNil
     to (Cons x xs) = Fix (PreCons x (to xs))

     fro :: List' a -> List a
     fro (MkFix PreNil)         = Nil
     fro (MkFix (PreCons x xs)) = Cons x (fro xs)

     -- and we can prove:
     -- > to . fro == id
     -- > fro . to == id

There's a whole bunch of other machinery that comes from this 
perspective, but the important thing is that it all depends on the fact 
that PreList is a functor in a very specific way, namely that it applies 
the function to all the recursion sites (i.e., "one level down" if we're 
thinking of the fixed-point version):

     instance Functor (PreList a) where
         fmap f PreNil         = PreNil
         fmap f (PreCons x xs) = PreCons x (f xs)

Of course, Fix(PreList a) ---aka List a--- has its own functor instance, 
but that's unrelated.

Live well,

More information about the Haskell-Cafe mailing list