[Haskell-cafe] [RFC] Preliminary benchmark graphs

Peter Lund firefly at vax64.dk
Thu Dec 20 05:57:17 EST 2007


I added Don's three benchmarks and redid all my benchmarks with:
  ghc 6.6.1
  ghc 6.8.2
  ghc 6.8.2 + bytestring 0.9.0.2
  ghc 6.9.20071119
  ghc 6.9.20071119 + bytestring 0.9.0.2
  ghc head-as-of-yesterday-around-noon
  ghc head-as-of-yesterday-around-noon + bytestring 0.9.0.2

I tried to get the draft emails with intro, methodology, discussion, and
conclusion completed yesterday but my brain simply wasn't up to it.

Unfortunately, it still isn't quite up to it :(

Since the perfect is the enemy of the good, I'll post the graphs for all
the above 7 runs now.

The rest will be forthcoming when I can think straight again, hopefully
some time in the evening.

I have scripts to help me install precisely the ghc version I want (and
to make it easy to duplicate my results).  I also have scripts to run
the benchmarks, get correct memory measurements (-sstderr doesn't seem
trustworthy), check the validity of each timing measurement, generate
I/O traces, generate reports, and finally merging reports from different
runs with or without rescaling.

This attached report uses rescaling since I'm compiling different
compiler/library combinations on the same machine.

One thing that shows up very clearly in the graphs is that the memory
situation is bad and that Don's recent fix only really solves the
problem on 6.8.2, not on head.

Another thing is that the backend really lets us down.  I have
hand-tweaked a simple byte counting benchmark and a simple space
counting benchmark through increasing degrees of refinement from the
banal to the heroic and timed those, too.  It seems like improved
register use alone would halve the run time.  Add a sprinkling of MMX
heroics and things get even better (but that's not realistic or even a
good idea at the moment).  The reason why lazy bytestrings perform so
badly, speed-wise, is most likely a backend that doesn't do hoisting of
"bounds checks" out of loops.

-Peter

-------------- next part --------------
charybdis
ghc 6.6.1
AMD Athlon(tm) 64 Processor 3000+
2009.160 MHz
TESTKIND=THOROUGH
SUFFIX=


charybdis
ghc 6.8.2
AMD Athlon(tm) 64 Processor 3000+
2009.160 MHz
TESTKIND=THOROUGH
SUFFIX=


charybdis
ghc 6.8.2
AMD Athlon(tm) 64 Processor 3000+
2009.160 MHz
TESTKIND=THOROUGH
SUFFIX=-bs0.9.0.2


charybdis
ghc 6.9.20071119
AMD Athlon(tm) 64 Processor 3000+
2009.160 MHz
TESTKIND=THOROUGH
SUFFIX=


charybdis
ghc 6.9.20071119
AMD Athlon(tm) 64 Processor 3000+
2009.160 MHz
TESTKIND=THOROUGH
SUFFIX=-bs0.9.0.2


charybdis
ghc 6.9.20071217
AMD Athlon(tm) 64 Processor 3000+
2009.160 MHz
TESTKIND=THOROUGH
SUFFIX=


charybdis
ghc 6.9.20071217
AMD Athlon(tm) 64 Processor 3000+
2009.160 MHz
TESTKIND=THOROUGH
SUFFIX=-bs0.9.0.2


Time (byte counting)           std
--------------------       avg dev slack
hs/byte-bs----acc:       1.020 40? 0.0  ??????                                |
 --                      0.703  5? 0.4  ????                                  |
 --                      0.702  7? 0.3  ????                                  |
 --                      0.705  7? 0.1  ????                                  |
 --                      0.712  3? 0.1  ????                                  |
 --                      0.706  7? 0.1  ????                                  |
 --                      0.707  7? 0.9  ????                                  |
hs/byte-bs----foldlx:    0.789  3? 0.3  ????                                  |
 --                      0.993  2? 0.2  ?????                                 |
 --                      1.102  1? 0.2  ??????                                |
 --                      1.002  1? 0.5  ??????                                |
 --                      1.112  1? 0.3  ??????                                |
 --                      1.024  2? 0.2  ??????                                |
 --                      1.111  1? 0.1  ??????                                |
hs/byte-bs----foldrx:    0.813  3? 0.1  ?????                                 |
 --                      1.102  2? 0.3  ??????                                |
 --                      1.100  1? 0.1  ??????                                |
 --                      1.112  2? 0.1  ??????                                |
 --                      1.114  1? 0.4  ??????                                |
 --                      1.113  2? 0.5  ??????                                |
 --                      1.112  1? 0.2  ??????                                |
hs/byte-bsl---acc:       3.599 13? 0.0  ???????????????????                   |
 --                      2.609 17? 0.0  ??????????????                        |
 --                      2.560 15? 0.1  ?????????????                         |
 --                      2.595 14? 0.1  ??????????????                        |
 --                      2.574 16? 0.1  ?????????????                         |
 --                      2.613 12? 0.2  ??????????????                        |
 --                      2.656 44? 0.1  ??????????????                        |
hs/byte-xxxxx-acc-1:     4.606  5? 0.0  ????????????????????????              |
 --                      4.730  3? 0.0  ????????????????????????              |
 --                      4.722  3? 0.1  ????????????????????????              |
 --                      4.436  5? 0.0  ???????????????????????               |
 --                      4.500  6? 0.1  ???????????????????????               |
 --                      4.462  4? 0.1  ???????????????????????               |
 --                      4.499  7? 0.1  ???????????????????????               |
hs/byte-xxxxx-acc-2:     4.595  5? 0.0  ????????????????????????              |
 --                      4.704  1? 0.0  ????????????????????????              |
 --                      4.722  6? 0.0  ????????????????????????              |
 --                      4.473  8? 0.0  ???????????????????????               |
 --                      4.493  5? 0.0  ???????????????????????               |
 --                      4.477  3? 0.1  ???????????????????????               |
 --                      4.446  2? 0.0  ???????????????????????               |
hs/byte-xxxxx-foldl:     4.566  9? 0.0  ????????????????????????              |
 --                      4.754  6? 0.1  ?????????????????????????             |
 --                      4.735  7? 0.0  ????????????????????????              |
 --                      4.412 10? 0.0  ???????????????????????               |
 --                      4.486  3? 0.0  ???????????????????????               |
 --                      4.473  3? 0.0  ???????????????????????               |
 --                      4.511 10? 0.1  ???????????????????????               |


Memory:                    Peak
-------                     KB 
hs/byte-bs----acc:       147448 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147500 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147616 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147752 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147732 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147772 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147780 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
hs/byte-bs----foldlx:    147468 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147528 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147624 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147748 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147736 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147796 ?????????????????????????????????????????     |
 --                      147780 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
hs/byte-bs----foldrx:    147452 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147500 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147624 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147744 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147740 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147772 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147784 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
hs/byte-bsl---acc:         2872 ?                                             |
 --                        2920 ?                                             |
 --                        3040 ?                                             |
 --                        3172 ?                                             |
 --                        3184 ?                                             |
 --                        3212 ?                                             |
 --                        3216 ?                                             |
hs/byte-xxxxx-acc-1:       1572 ?                                             |
 --                        1632 ?                                             |
 --                        1636 ?                                             |
 --                        1904 ?                                             |
 --                        1904 ?                                             |
 --                        1900 ?                                             |
 --                        1900 ?                                             |
hs/byte-xxxxx-acc-2:       1568 ?                                             |
 --                        1636 ?                                             |
 --                        1636 ?                                             |
 --                        1904 ?                                             |
 --                        1900 ?                                             |
 --                        1900 ?                                             |
 --                        1896 ?                                             |
hs/byte-xxxxx-foldl:       1572 ?                                             |
 --                        1632 ?                                             |
 --                        1636 ?                                             |
 --                        1900 ?                                             |
 --                        1904 ?                                             |
 --                        1900 ?                                             |
 --                        1896 ?                                             |


Time (space counting)          std
---------------------      avg dev slack
hs/space-bs-c8-acc-1:    1.287 20? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      1.131  2? 0.1  ??????                                |
 --                      1.132  2? 0.3  ??????                                |
 --                      1.145  1? 0.2  ??????                                |
 --                      1.150  1? 0.2  ??????                                |
 --                      1.147  2? 0.1  ??????                                |
 --                      1.147  2? 0.2  ??????                                |
hs/space-bs-c8-count:    0.770  2? 0.0  ????                                  |
 --                      0.711  1? 0.4  ????                                  |
 --                      0.513  2? 0.2  ???                                   |
 --                      0.521  1? 0.2  ???                                   |
 --                      0.523  3? 0.2  ???                                   |
 --                      0.522  5? 0.2  ???                                   |
 --                      0.523  3? 0.6  ???                                   |
hs/space-bs-c8-foldlx-1: 1.272  1? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      1.205  2? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      1.164  3? 0.0  ??????                                |
 --                      1.221  1? 0.1  ???????                               |
 --                      1.176  1? 0.3  ??????                                |
 --                      1.259  1? 0.1  ???????                               |
 --                      1.176  1? 0.2  ??????                                |
hs/space-bs-c8-foldlx-2: 1.270  1? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      1.207  1? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      1.165  2? 0.1  ??????                                |
 --                      1.219  2? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      1.176  1? 0.3  ??????                                |
 --                      1.258  1? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      1.177  1? 0.2  ??????                                |
hs/space-bs-c8-foldrx:   1.064  2? 0.1  ??????                                |
 --                      1.168  2? 0.2  ??????                                |
 --                      1.164  1? 0.3  ??????                                |
 --                      1.172  2? 0.3  ??????                                |
 --                      1.177  1? 0.2  ??????                                |
 --                      1.176  1? 0.2  ??????                                |
 --                      1.176  1? 0.1  ??????                                |
hs/space-bs-c8-lenfil:   1.271  1? 0.1  ???????                               |
 --                      1.218  1? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      0.541  3? 0.2  ???                                   |
 --                      1.223  1? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      0.549  1? 0.4  ???                                   |
 --                      1.225  1? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      0.551  5? 0.4  ???                                   |
hs/space-bslc8-acc-1:    6.367 17? 0.2  ?????????????????????????????????     |
 --                      3.396  7? 0.1  ??????????????????                    |
 --                      3.508  4? 0.1  ??????????????????                    |
 --                      3.388 10? 0.1  ??????????????????                    |
 --                      3.441 10? 0.1  ??????????????????                    |
 --                      3.438  3? 0.0  ??????????????????                    |
 --                      3.434 13? 0.1  ??????????????????                    |
hs/space-bslc8-acc-2:    6.150 21? 0.0  ????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      3.470  5? 0.0  ??????????????????                    |
 --                      3.439 10? 0.1  ??????????????????                    |
 --                      3.386  5? 0.1  ??????????????????                    |
 --                      3.479 11? 0.1  ??????????????????                    |
 --                      3.467  6? 0.1  ??????????????????                    |
 --                      3.470 10? 0.1  ??????????????????                    |
hs/space-bslc8-acc-3:    4.041 21? 0.1  ?????????????????????                 |
 --                      2.959 13? 0.0  ???????????????                       |
 --                      2.920 16? 0.1  ???????????????                       |
 --                      2.832  4? 0.1  ???????????????                       |
 --                      2.925 14? 0.1  ???????????????                       |
 --                      2.987  9? 0.0  ????????????????                      |
 --                      2.996 20? 0.1  ????????????????                      |
hs/space-bslc8-count:    0.713  1? 0.3  ????                                  |
 --                      0.735  1? 0.4  ????                                  |
 --                      0.431  0? 0.7  ???                                   |
 --                      0.477  2? 0.4  ???                                   |
 --                      0.482  1? 0.4  ???                                   |
 --                      0.479  1? 0.6  ???                                   |
 --                      0.482  2? 0.4  ???                                   |
hs/space-bslc8-foldl:    1.431  1? 0.3  ????????                              |
 --                      1.398  1? 0.2  ????????                              |
 --                      1.197  1? 0.2  ??????                                |
 --                      1.458  1? 0.3  ????????                              |
 --                      1.059  0? 0.0  ??????                                |
 --                      1.459  1? 0.1  ????????                              |
 --                      1.061  0? 0.4  ??????                                |
hs/space-bslc8-foldlx-1: 1.430  1? 0.1  ????????                              |
 --                      1.400  1? 0.1  ????????                              |
 --                      1.197  1? 0.0  ??????                                |
 --                      1.458  0? 0.1  ????????                              |
 --                      1.060  1? 0.0  ??????                                |
 --                      1.457  1? 0.1  ????????                              |
 --                      1.060  1? 0.2  ??????                                |
hs/space-bslc8-foldlx-2: 1.431  1? 0.1  ????????                              |
 --                      1.399  1? 0.1  ????????                              |
 --                      1.196  1? 0.1  ??????                                |
 --                      1.457  1? 0.1  ????????                              |
 --                      1.060  1? 0.3  ??????                                |
 --                      1.458  1? 0.1  ????????                              |
 --                      1.060  1? 0.0  ??????                                |
hs/space-bslc8-foldr-1:  1.748  1? 0.0  ?????????                             |
 --                      1.579  2? 0.1  ????????                              |
 --                      1.220  2? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      1.312  1? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      1.213  1? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      1.325  4? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      1.213  2? 0.2  ???????                               |
hs/space-bslc8-foldr-2:  1.745  1? 0.1  ?????????                             |
 --                      1.579  2? 0.1  ????????                              |
 --                      1.220  1? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      1.315  1? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      1.210  1? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      1.317  4? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      1.213  2? 0.2  ???????                               |
hs/space-bslc8-lenfil-1: 1.521  7? 0.2  ????????                              |
 --                      1.295  1? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      0.429  0? 0.2  ???                                   |
 --                      1.323  1? 0.1  ???????                               |
 --                      0.483  2? 0.4  ???                                   |
 --                      1.327  1? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      0.482  2? 0.4  ???                                   |
hs/space-bslc8-lenfil-2: 1.532  6? 0.1  ????????                              |
 --                      1.296  0? 0.0  ???????                               |
 --                      0.429  0? 0.2  ???                                   |
 --                      1.325  1? 0.1  ???????                               |
 --                      0.483  1? 0.6  ???                                   |
 --                      1.327  1? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      0.482  2? 0.4  ???                                   |
hs/space-bsl---foldlx:   1.288  1? 0.2  ???????                               |
 --                      1.333  1? 0.0  ???????                               |
 --                      1.168  1? 0.2  ??????                                |
 --                      1.391  1? 0.1  ???????                               |
 --                      1.006  1? 0.3  ??????                                |
 --                      1.395  1? 0.1  ????????                              |
 --                      1.008  1? 0.2  ??????                                |
hs/space-xxxxx-acc-1:    5.036  7? 0.1  ??????????????????????????            |
 --                      5.381  6? 0.0  ????????????????????????????          |
 --                      5.358  8? 0.1  ????????????????????????????          |
 --                      4.991  1? 0.1  ??????????????????????????            |
 --                      5.047  7? 0.1  ??????????????????????????            |
 --                      5.051  3? 0.1  ??????????????????????????            |
 --                      5.049  4? 0.1  ??????????????????????????            |
hs/space-xxxxx-acc-2:    5.009  7? 0.1  ??????????????????????????            |
 --                      5.437  4? 0.1  ????????????????????????????          |
 --                      5.406  2? 0.0  ????????????????????????????          |
 --                      4.985  1? 0.0  ??????????????????????????            |
 --                      5.057  4? 0.1  ??????????????????????????            |
 --                      5.048  6? 0.1  ??????????????????????????            |
 --                      5.089  6? 0.0  ??????????????????????????            |
hs/space-xxxxx-foldl:    5.024  5? 0.0  ??????????????????????????            |
 --                      5.371  9? 0.0  ????????????????????????????          |
 --                      5.301  9? 0.1  ???????????????????????????           |
 --                      5.035  2? 0.1  ??????????????????????????            |
 --                      5.037  3? 0.0  ??????????????????????????            |
 --                      5.046  4? 0.0  ??????????????????????????            |
 --                      5.042  4? 0.0  ??????????????????????????            |
hs/space-xxxxx-lenfil:   7.042  4? 0.0  ????????????????????????????????????  |
 --                      7.505  3? 0.0  ??????????????????????????????????????|
 --                      7.498  3? 0.0  ??????????????????????????????????????|
 --                      7.106  8? 0.1  ????????????????????????????????????  |
 --                      7.092  3? 0.1  ????????????????????????????????????  |
 --                      7.083  3? 0.0  ????????????????????????????????????  |
 --                      7.121  5? 0.1  ????????????????????????????????????  |
hs/space-bslc8-chunk-1:    n/a
 --                      1.054  0? 0.3  ??????                                |
 --                      1.053  1? 0.1  ??????                                |
 --                      1.094  0? 0.3  ??????                                |
 --                      1.088  0? 0.0  ??????                                |
 --                      1.096  1? 0.1  ??????                                |
 --                      1.089  0? 0.6  ??????                                |
hs/space-bslc8-chunk-2:    n/a
 --                      1.055  0? 0.3  ??????                                |
 --                      1.053  0? 0.1  ??????                                |
 --                      1.094  1? 0.3  ??????                                |
 --                      1.088  1? 0.2  ??????                                |
 --                      1.096  1? 0.2  ??????                                |
 --                      1.089  0? 0.1  ??????                                |
hs/space-bslc8-chunk-3:    n/a
 --                      1.190  4? 0.2  ??????                                |
 --                      1.199  1? 0.3  ???????                               |
 --                      1.087  1? 0.3  ??????                                |
 --                      1.051  1? 0.4  ??????                                |
 --                      1.077  1? 0.1  ??????                                |
 --                      1.053  1? 0.2  ??????                                |
hs/space-bslc8-chunk-4:    n/a
 --                      1.054  0? 0.2  ??????                                |
 --                      1.054  0? 0.2  ??????                                |
 --                      1.099  0? 0.3  ??????                                |
 --                      1.097  1? 0.1  ??????                                |
 --                      1.094  1? 0.2  ??????                                |
 --                      1.096  0? 0.0  ??????                                |


Memory:                    Peak
-------                     KB 
hs/space-bs-c8-acc-1:    147448 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147492 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147608 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147736 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147740 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147752 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147752 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
hs/space-bs-c8-count:    147448 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147500 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147612 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147744 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147756 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147764 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147776 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
hs/space-bs-c8-foldlx-1: 147468 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147524 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147608 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147756 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147744 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147796 ?????????????????????????????????????????     |
 --                      147752 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
hs/space-bs-c8-foldlx-2: 147468 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147520 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147608 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147752 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147748 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147796 ?????????????????????????????????????????     |
 --                      147756 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
hs/space-bs-c8-foldrx:   147448 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147496 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147608 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147732 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147748 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147760 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147756 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
hs/space-bs-c8-lenfil:   147464 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      147524 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      167176 ??????????????????????????????????????????????|
 --                      147756 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      167300 ??????????????????????????????????????????????|
 --                      147788 ????????????????????????????????????????      |
 --                      167320 ??????????????????????????????????????????????|
hs/space-bslc8-acc-1:      2872 ?                                             |
 --                        2920 ?                                             |
 --                        3048 ?                                             |
 --                        3192 ?                                             |
 --                        3228 ?                                             |
 --                        3180 ?                                             |
 --                        3196 ?                                             |
hs/space-bslc8-acc-2:      2872 ?                                             |
 --                        2924 ?                                             |
 --                        3048 ?                                             |
 --                        3192 ?                                             |
 --                        3228 ?                                             |
 --                        3180 ?                                             |
 --                        3200 ?                                             |
hs/space-bslc8-acc-3:      2868 ?                                             |
 --                        2924 ?                                             |
 --                        3052 ?                                             |
 --                        3196 ?                                             |
 --                        3232 ?                                             |
 --                        3172 ?                                             |
 --                        3208 ?                                             |
hs/space-bslc8-count:      1476 ?                                             |
 --                        1520 ?                                             |
 --                        1656 ?                                             |
 --                       79204 ??????????????????????                        |
 --                       82248 ???????????????????????                       |
 --                       79220 ??????????????????????                        |
 --                       82224 ???????????????????????                       |
hs/space-bslc8-foldl:      1552 ?                                             |
 --                        1620 ?                                             |
 --                        1632 ?                                             |
 --                       85868 ????????????????????????                      |
 --                       79224 ??????????????????????                        |
 --                       85852 ????????????????????????                      |
 --                       79196 ??????????????????????                        |
hs/space-bslc8-foldlx-1:   1556 ?                                             |
 --                        1620 ?                                             |
 --                        1636 ?                                             |
 --                       85864 ????????????????????????                      |
 --                       79224 ??????????????????????                        |
 --                       85852 ????????????????????????                      |
 --                       79196 ??????????????????????                        |
hs/space-bslc8-foldlx-2:   1552 ?                                             |
 --                        1616 ?                                             |
 --                        1636 ?                                             |
 --                       85868 ????????????????????????                      |
 --                       79224 ??????????????????????                        |
 --                       85852 ????????????????????????                      |
 --                       79196 ??????????????????????                        |
hs/space-bslc8-foldr-1:  169480 ??????????????????????????????????????????????|
 --                      169544 ??????????????????????????????????????????????|
 --                      149076 ?????????????????????????????????????????     |
 --                      169700 ??????????????????????????????????????????????|
 --                      149704 ?????????????????????????????????????????     |
 --                      169680 ??????????????????????????????????????????????|
 --                      149680 ?????????????????????????????????????????     |
hs/space-bslc8-foldr-2:  169480 ??????????????????????????????????????????????|
 --                      169544 ??????????????????????????????????????????????|
 --                      149076 ?????????????????????????????????????????     |
 --                      169700 ??????????????????????????????????????????????|
 --                      149708 ?????????????????????????????????????????     |
 --                      169676 ??????????????????????????????????????????????|
 --                      149676 ?????????????????????????????????????????     |
hs/space-bslc8-lenfil-1:  38632 ???????????                                   |
 --                       38644 ???????????                                   |
 --                        1940 ?                                             |
 --                      109404 ??????????????????????????????                |
 --                       82324 ???????????????????????                       |
 --                      109388 ??????????????????????????????                |
 --                       82304 ???????????????????????                       |
hs/space-bslc8-lenfil-2:  38628 ???????????                                   |
 --                       38648 ???????????                                   |
 --                        1940 ?                                             |
 --                      109404 ??????????????????????????????                |
 --                       82328 ???????????????????????                       |
 --                      109392 ??????????????????????????????                |
 --                       82300 ???????????????????????                       |
hs/space-bsl---foldlx:     1560 ?                                             |
 --                        1616 ?                                             |
 --                        1620 ?                                             |
 --                       85836 ????????????????????????                      |
 --                       79184 ??????????????????????                        |
 --                       85864 ????????????????????????                      |
 --                       79208 ??????????????????????                        |
hs/space-xxxxx-acc-1:      1568 ?                                             |
 --                        1636 ?                                             |
 --                        1636 ?                                             |
 --                        1904 ?                                             |
 --                        1904 ?                                             |
 --                        1900 ?                                             |
 --                        1904 ?                                             |
hs/space-xxxxx-acc-2:      1572 ?                                             |
 --                        1636 ?                                             |
 --                        1636 ?                                             |
 --                        1904 ?                                             |
 --                        1900 ?                                             |
 --                        1904 ?                                             |
 --                        1900 ?                                             |
hs/space-xxxxx-foldl:      1572 ?                                             |
 --                        1636 ?                                             |
 --                        1636 ?                                             |
 --                        1900 ?                                             |
 --                        1904 ?                                             |
 --                        1904 ?                                             |
 --                        1904 ?                                             |
hs/space-xxxxx-lenfil:     1556 ?                                             |
 --                        1608 ?                                             |
 --                        1604 ?                                             |
 --                        1892 ?                                             |
 --                        1892 ?                                             |
 --                        1888 ?                                             |
 --                        1888 ?                                             |
hs/space-bslc8-chunk-1:     n/a
 --                        1512 ?                                             |
 --                        1636 ?                                             |
 --                       65192 ??????????????????                            |
 --                       66216 ??????????????????                            |
 --                       65204 ??????????????????                            |
 --                       66224 ??????????????????                            |
hs/space-bslc8-chunk-2:     n/a
 --                        1512 ?                                             |
 --                        1640 ?                                             |
 --                       65192 ??????????????????                            |
 --                       66216 ??????????????????                            |
 --                       65204 ??????????????????                            |
 --                       66228 ??????????????????                            |
hs/space-bslc8-chunk-3:     n/a
 --                        1548 ?                                             |
 --                        1644 ?                                             |
 --                       75240 ?????????????????????                         |
 --                       66208 ??????????????????                            |
 --                       75216 ?????????????????????                         |
 --                       66224 ??????????????????                            |
hs/space-bslc8-chunk-4:     n/a
 --                        1512 ?                                             |
 --                        1636 ?                                             |
 --                       76188 ?????????????????????                         |
 --                       79232 ??????????????????????                        |
 --                       76176 ?????????????????????                         |
 --                       79204 ??????????????????????                        |


More information about the Haskell-Cafe mailing list