How to describe this bug?
twhitehead at gmail.com
Wed Jul 11 18:05:40 CEST 2012
On July 11, 2012 04:51:50 Christian Maeder wrote:
> Is it not enough to store floats into memory just before equality tests
> (or add rounding in the instance definitions of Float and Double in Eq
> and Ord)?
You have to be 100% consistent in how you do every operations in all cases
otherwise different levels of rounding errors will creep into the results.
It isn't too hard to imagine a floating point expression getting inlined
somewhere, and the compiler generating code to evalulate it all in registers.
Intermediate operations will then be done to 80 bit precision.
Elsewhere, it doesn't get inlined and the compiler generates code to store
intermediate results in memory. Intermediate operations will then be done to
32 bit precision. Different results will occur on the rounding boundaires.
Always storing and reloading after every operations will give you consistent
results. I guess the other option is to disable inlining etc. or somehow
ensure they are applied consistently in all use cases of an expression.
More information about the Glasgow-haskell-users