[Haskell-beginners] Are functors in Haskell always injective?
Dimitri DeFigueiredo
defigueiredo at ucdavis.edu
Sat Jul 5 05:42:56 UTC 2014
Hi All,
My understanding is that a functor in Haskell is made of two "maps".
One that maps objects to objects that in Hask means types into types
(i.e. a type constructor)
And one that maps arrows into arrows, i.e. fmap.
My understanding is that a functor F in category theory is required to
preserve the domain and codomain of arrows, but it doesn't have to be
injective. In other words, two objects X and Y of category C (i.e. two
types in Hask) can be mapped into the same object Z (same type) in
category Z. As long as the "homomorphism" law holds:
F(f:X->Y) = F(f):F(X)->F(Y)
However, I don't think there is any way this mapping of types cannot be
injective in Haskell. It seems that a type constructor, when called with
two distinct type will always yield another two *distinct* types. (E.g.
Int and Fload yield Maybe Int and Maybe) So, it seems that Functors in
Haskell are actually more restrictive than functors can be in general.
Is this observation correct or did I misunderstand something?
Thanks!
Dimitri
More information about the Beginners
mailing list